Buona Beef Tuna Genovese Copycat Recipe (Tastes Just Like the Real One)

Table of Contents

Introduction

If you’ve ever tasted Buona’s Tuna Genovese sandwich, you know why fans still crave it. The creamy yet zesty tuna, the briny punch of capers, and the crunch of tangy pickled veggies all hugged by toasted Italian bread—yeah, it was unforgettable. Sadly, it’s no longer on the official menu, but don’t worry. This buona beef tuna genovese copycat recipe brings that same flavor home. It’s easy to make, loaded with Mediterranean-inspired ingredients, and totally satisfying. Whether for weekday lunches or a quick dinner with flair, this sandwich is about to become your new favorite.

Print

The Story Behind the Buona Beef Tuna Genovese Copycat Recipe Sandwich

Why Buona’s Tuna Genovese Left a Mark

When you think of Buona Beef, your mind probably jumps to juicy Italian beef sandwiches, sausages, and loaded hot dogs. So when their Tuna Genovese sandwich hit the menu, it raised eyebrows—but won hearts. It was bold, unexpected, and honestly kind of genius. This wasn’t your standard mayo-heavy deli tuna. It leaned into olive oil, lemon, garlic, capers, red onion, and herbs, wrapped together in a blend that felt like Italy and Chicago shook hands.

The result? A sandwich that felt familiar but exciting, comforting but bright. It stood out for its flavor and simplicity, letting high-quality tuna and thoughtful ingredients do all the talking. No wonder it developed a cult following. Now that it’s disappeared from the menu, recreating it at home is our only option—and fortunately, it’s a delicious one.

We’ll show you how to craft every layer of this craveable combo, using ingredients you probably already have. This isn’t just a tuna sandwich. It’s a nod to Genova, a little Chicago attitude, and a whole lot of flavor.

My First Taste: Lisa Kane’s Memory

Hi, I’m Lisa Kane, the voice behind EasyCookedRecipes.com. The first time I had Buona’s Tuna Genovese, it instantly transported me. I was raised by a Moroccan mom and an American dad. My mom would pack jars of preserved lemon and tuna in olive oil during the summer, layering them into warm flatbreads. My dad, on the other hand, loved hoagies stacked with pickles and mustard on football Sundays. This sandwich? It tasted like both their worlds collided—in the best way.

It had my mom’s pantry in it: garlic, herbs, olive oil. But the vinegar, the bold crunch, the ciabatta warmth—that was Dad’s kitchen. And Buona nailed it. That first bite reminded me why I love fusion cooking and why simple ingredients, treated right, can leave lasting memories.

That’s why this buona beef tuna genovese copycat recipe is so close to my heart. It’s easy, bright, savory, and perfect for sharing—even on a busy night when time’s tight and everyone’s hungry.

Breaking Down the Buona Tuna Genovese Flavor

What Is Genovese-Style Tuna?

To understand the magic of Buona’s Tuna Genovese, you have to start with what makes “Genovese-style” so irresistible. This isn’t your classic tuna salad with mayo and celery. No, Genovese-style tuna celebrates the bold and briny ingredients from the Ligurian coast of Italy—think fresh herbs, capers, lemon, garlic, and quality olive oil. It’s a punchy, elegant twist on an everyday protein.

Italian canned tuna (often packed in olive oil) is the key. It has a firmer texture and richer taste than typical water-packed versions. Combine that with red wine vinegar or lemon juice, chopped red onion, minced garlic, parsley, and salty capers, and you’ve got a base that’s as flavorful as it is refreshing.

This mix gets better as it sits. The tuna absorbs the sharpness of the vinegar and the aroma of the herbs. The capers pop with tang. Garlic mellows. Olive oil binds it all together. The flavor? Vibrant, savory, and undeniably Mediterranean.

And the best part? You don’t need fancy ingredients to pull it off. Most of what you need is probably in your kitchen right now.

Why It Works So Well on a Sandwich

A sandwich is only as good as its contrasts, and Buona’s Tuna Genovese nailed the balance. Here’s why:

• Texture: The tuna is moist but not soggy. It’s creamy from the olive oil, but firm enough to hold its shape. Paired with toasted bread? Perfect contrast.
• Acidity: Vinegar or lemon juice cuts through the richness, keeping each bite light and bright.
• Salt & Umami: Capers and garlic add intensity, while anchovy (optional, but highly recommended) deepens the savory flavor.
• Crunch: This sandwich often had shaved red onion or maybe even a bit of giardiniera—adding bite and color.

Buona served theirs warm or toasted, enhancing the flavors and making it melty without being greasy. The toasting added a crisp shell, the tuna filling steamed inside, and the aroma of garlic and herbs filled every bite.

You can even customize yours. Add a swipe of Dijon for more kick, arugula for bitterness, or roasted peppers for sweetness. That’s the beauty of building this at home.

Gathering the Ingredients for Your Copycat Recipe (Buona Beef Tuna Genovese Copycat Recipe)

Pantry Staples You’ll Need

The secret to an authentic buona beef tuna genovese copycat recipe lies in using bold, simple ingredients—no shortcuts. Each component plays a role in flavor, texture, or aroma. Here’s what you’ll need to recreate that restaurant-style sandwich at home:

• Italian-style canned tuna in olive oil – Skip the water-packed stuff. Go for solid-packed tuna in olive oil (like Genova or Rio Mare). The texture and flavor are everything.
• Extra virgin olive oil – Used to enrich the tuna mixture and add smoothness.
• Fresh lemon juice – Adds brightness and acidity.
• Red wine vinegar – Boosts that tangy Genovese punch.
• Garlic (fresh and minced) – Adds heat and aroma. One small clove is plenty.
• Capers – Salty and briny, they’re essential for a real Genovese flavor.
• Red onion (finely chopped) – Gives bite and freshness.
• Flat-leaf parsley (chopped) – Adds color and clean herbal notes.
• Dijon mustard (optional) – A small dab deepens the flavor, but it’s totally your call.
• Salt & cracked black pepper – Just a pinch to season the mix perfectly.
• Crusty Italian bread or ciabatta rolls – Needs to be hearty enough to hold the filling and lightly toasted.

These ingredients together create that bold, zesty tuna blend that made Buona’s sandwich so popular. With quality canned tuna and good bread, you’re already halfway there.

Optional Add-Ons to Elevate It

One thing that made Buona’s version sing was the smart layering of flavors. If you want to go all-in, consider these toppings and mix-ins:

• Giardiniera – Adds tang, crunch, and mild heat.
• Roasted red peppers – Sweet and smoky, perfect for contrast.
• Arugula – Peppery greens to cut the richness.
• Pepperoncini or banana peppers – For that vinegary zing.
• Homemade garlic aioli – If you want a creamy kick on the bread.
• Anchovy paste or mashed anchovy filet (optional) – Adds deep umami without tasting fishy.
• Provolone cheese (thin slice) – If you’re toasting it and want a melty layer.

These are entirely optional, but if you’re building the sandwich for guests or just want a full Buona-style experience, they’ll take it up a notch.

Step-by-Step Copycat Recipe(Buona Beef Tuna Genovese Copycat Recipe) Instructions

Mixing the Tuna Genovese Base

This filling is the soul of the sandwich—zesty, savory, and loaded with layers of flavor. Here’s exactly how to make it:

Ingredients:

• 2 cans (5–7 oz) Italian tuna in olive oil, drained but not rinsed
• 2 tablespoons extra virgin olive oil
• 1 tablespoon fresh lemon juice
• 2 teaspoons red wine vinegar
• 1 small garlic clove, minced
• 1 tablespoon capers, roughly chopped
• 2 tablespoons red onion, finely chopped
• 1 tablespoon fresh parsley, chopped
• Salt and cracked black pepper to taste
• (Optional) ½ teaspoon Dijon mustard
• (Optional) ½ teaspoon anchovy paste

Instructions:

1. In a medium mixing bowl, flake the drained tuna gently with a fork to keep some texture.
2. Add olive oil, lemon juice, and vinegar. Stir gently until the tuna is glossy but not wet.
3. Fold in garlic, capers, red onion, parsley, and mustard (if using).
4. Taste, then season with a pinch of salt and a few grinds of black pepper.
5. Let it rest in the fridge for 10–15 minutes to allow the flavors to mingle.

This blend is bold and briny, perfect as a sandwich filling or even as a dip for crusty bread.

Assembling the Sandwich, Buona-Style

You’ve made the filling—now let’s build it like Buona did, with all the textures and flavors layered just right.

You’ll Need:

• Crusty Italian bread or ciabatta roll, sliced and lightly toasted
• Optional toppings: giardiniera, roasted peppers, provolone, arugula, garlic aioli

Assembly Steps:

1. Toast your bread until crisp outside but still soft inside. A warm sandwich holds flavor better.
2. Spread the bottom half of the bread with a thin layer of garlic aioli or Dijon if using.
3. Pile on a generous scoop of your Tuna Genovese mix, slightly pressing it into the bread so it holds.
4. Top with roasted peppers, giardiniera, or arugula, if desired.
5. Add provolone, then quickly return the sandwich to a hot pan or panini press (1–2 minutes) just to melt.
6. Cap it with the other slice of bread and slice in half to serve.

You’ll notice the balance instantly—the bright tuna, the crunch of giardiniera, the silkiness of olive oil, and the warm bread all collide beautifully. It’s satisfying without being heavy and definitely a crowd-pleaser.

Serving Suggestions

What to Pair with Your Tuna Genovese

Once your sandwich is stacked and toasty, it’s time to think about sides that complement the flavor without overpowering it. This is where a little planning makes your homemade Buona moment feel restaurant-level. Whether you’re serving it for lunch, dinner, or a casual get-together, these pairings keep the balance fresh and flavorful:

• Crispy kettle-cooked chips – The crunch echoes the pickled elements in the sandwich.
• Chilled Italian pasta salad – Vinegar-based with olives, tomatoes, and herbs. Avoid mayo—it competes with the tuna’s richness.
• Lemon or herbed couscous – Light, fluffy, and citrusy, a great side for warmer days.
• Simple tomato cucumber salad – Drizzled with olive oil and oregano for a refreshing bite.
• Sparkling water or limonata – The acidity helps cut through the olive oil and tuna, just like wine would.

For a heartier meal, a warm bowl of creamy tomato basil soup also pairs beautifully, especially in cooler weather.

Make It a Meal: Family-Style Ideas

If you’re feeding more than just yourself, this buona beef tuna genovese copycat recipe can easily be transformed into a party platter or a weeknight family meal.

Here are a few ways to scale it up:

• Mini ciabatta sliders – Slice the buns, toast, and let everyone build their own sandwich buffet-style. Great for game night or casual gatherings.
• Open-faced melts – Pile the tuna mix on toasted baguette slices, top with provolone, and broil until bubbly.
• Salad-style platter – Skip the bread and serve the tuna mix over a bed of mixed greens with pickled onions, olives, and cherry tomatoes for a light, gluten-free dinner.
• Picnic wraps – Wrap it in flour tortillas with arugula and red peppers for a grab-and-go lunch option.

These options work because the filling is flavorful enough to carry the meal, no matter the format.

Storing, Packing & Meal Prep Tips

How Long It Lasts in the Fridge

One of the best things about this buona beef tuna genovese copycat recipe is how well it keeps. The olive oil base actually helps the flavors deepen over time, making it a great candidate for make-ahead lunches or quick dinners.

Here’s how to store it right:

• Tuna mixture: Store in an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to 3 days. Stir it gently before serving, as the oil and lemon may settle.
• Bread: Keep your bread separate and store it at room temperature in a bread bag or wrapped in foil. Toast or warm it before assembling.
• Pre-assembled sandwiches: If you absolutely must prep the full sandwich ahead, wrap it tightly in parchment or foil and store in the fridge for up to 24 hours. But keep in mind—bread may soften from the filling.

For best texture and flavor, assemble just before eating.

Make-Ahead Tips for Busy Lunches

Meal prepping doesn’t have to mean sacrificing flavor or texture. Here are my go-to tricks for packing this sandwich like a pro:

• Layering matters: If adding wet toppings (like roasted peppers or giardiniera), place greens like arugula or a thin slice of cheese between them and the bread to create a moisture barrier.
• Separate containers: Store tuna filling and toppings in small containers or a bento box until it’s time to eat, then assemble fresh.
• Pack with crackers or pita chips: For a deconstructed option, scoop the tuna salad like a dip.
• Wrap tightly: Use parchment followed by foil or beeswax wrap to hold the sandwich together and prevent air exposure.

Whether you’re packing lunch for work, school, or a road trip, this dish travels well when prepped smartly.

Common Copycat Mistakes to Avoid (Buona Beef Tuna Genovese Copycat Recipe)

Using the Wrong Tuna

The biggest misstep in recreating Buona’s original? Grabbing the wrong can of tuna. This recipe thrives on rich flavor and firm texture. Water-packed tuna often turns out dry, chalky, and bland in a sandwich like this.

What to do instead:
Always choose solid or fillet-style Italian tuna in olive oil. Brands like Genova or Rio Mare are easy to find and deliver that meaty, clean flavor the sandwich needs. Flake it gently with a fork—don’t mash it like traditional tuna salad.

Skipping the Acidity

This recipe lives and breathes on balance. Skip the acidity, and you’re left with an oily, flat sandwich. Vinegar and citrus don’t just add flavor—they cut through the richness, brighten the herbs, and awaken the capers.

Don’t skip:

• Lemon juice – Use fresh only. Bottled lemon juice lacks the brightness.
• Red wine vinegar – Just a splash gives depth and classic Genovese tang.

Also, be cautious with how much olive oil you add. If the tuna is already packed in oil, you won’t need much more. Taste and adjust slowly.

Overmixing the Tuna

This isn’t your average mayo-loaded spread. Texture is essential. If you mash the tuna into a paste, you’ll lose that chunky, satisfying bite Buona’s sandwich had.

What to do instead:
Use a fork to gently separate the tuna flakes, folding the ingredients together rather than stirring aggressively.

Toasting the Bread Wrong

A too-crunchy crust can scrape your mouth, while under-toasted bread will soak up oil and get soggy. The goal? A light toast that crisps the outside while keeping the inside tender.

Tips:

• Toast open-faced in the oven for 2–4 minutes at 375°F.
• Don’t press the sandwich too hard in a panini press—it can squeeze out the filling.

Other Recipes You Might Love

If this buona beef tuna genovese copycat recipe hit all the right flavor notes for you, you’re in for a treat. These related dishes bring similar vibes—fresh, bold, and full of simple ingredients that pack a punch.

Italian Tuna Pasta Salad
Think of it as the picnic-ready cousin of this sandwich. It’s loaded with olive oil–packed tuna, bright veggies, and a tangy vinaigrette. Plus, no mayo in sight.

Copycat Potbelly Tuna Sandwich
Looking for another fast-casual tuna hit? This one’s creamy, crunchy, and customizable—another crowd-pleaser from my kitchen.

Homemade Italian Hoagie Roll
Why settle for store-bought bread? This easy hoagie roll recipe gives you that soft interior with just the right chew on the outside.

Chicago-Style Beef Sandwich (Weeknight Version)
Missing the Buona beef lineup? Try this simplified homemade version with all the flavor and none of the hassle.

Mediterranean Chickpea Tuna Bowl
No bread? No problem. This bowl blends tuna with chickpeas, olives, and herbs for a fresh, filling, and gluten-free option.

Creamy Garlic Dijon Aioli
This fast blender sauce is ideal for spreading on your Tuna Genovese sandwich or dunking roasted potatoes.

Zesty Giardiniera (Homemade)
Bring Chicago’s favorite pickle mix into your kitchen. Great for this sandwich—or any sandwich, really.

Moroccan Tuna Stuffed Peppers
A nod to my heritage, this recipe marries bold tuna with warm spices inside soft roasted peppers.

Conclusion

The Buona Beef Tuna Genovese Copycat Recipe may no longer be on the menu, but it’s alive and well in your kitchen. This sandwich proves that tuna doesn’t need mayo to be creamy, satisfying, or crave-worthy. With just a few Mediterranean staples—olive oil, lemon, garlic, capers—you’ll build a flavor-packed filling that’s as bold as it is fresh.

As a home cook raised on two continents, this recipe brings me back to both my Moroccan roots and my American kitchen. Whether you serve it warm on toasted ciabatta or chilled with a crisp salad, it’s a reminder that great food doesn’t need to be fancy—it just needs to be real.

Now it’s your turn. Grab a fork, mix up that tuna, and bring back the sandwich that had Chicago hooked.
for more recipes follow us on pinterest

FAQs about the Buona Beef Tuna Genovese Copycat Recipe